Unknown Soldier #18 – Review

by Joshua Dysart (writer), Alberto Ponticelli (art), Oscar Celestini (colors), and Clem Robins (letters)

The Story: As his mind continues to unravel, Moses prepares to make the trade: medicine for rifles.

What’s Good: All told, this is an astoundingly good issue of Unknown Soldier, effectively balancing Moses’ personal struggles with the more public, social issues at stake in Dysart’s comic, something that has probably been the biggest challenge for the series.  It does so through being an outstanding tragedy on both fronts.

With Moses, the sense of tragedy is bitterly disappointing; Dysart makes it hard not to feel bad for the guy.  I won’t spoil anything, but this month really gives off that classic “just when you think you’re out, they pull you back in” theme that great tragedy always strives for.  So much of the progress Moses thought he was making turns out to be an illusion, with the only question being to what extent.  Clearly, his consciousness is decaying and what’s worse is that Moses is apparently less aware and less able to control that deterioration than any of us thought.  Psychologically speaking, this is the lowest and most precarious he has ever been.  It’s horrifying, particularly when you realize the scope of these new introspective developments.

On a cultural level, Dysart gives us the sort of tragedy that is simply paralyzing, depressing even.  He says a lot both about the nature of humanity when desperation strikes, as well as the demons of superstition that haunt and madden the Acholi people.  As hope is lost, the people fall back to outrageous folklore, leading them to senseless bloodshed.  In many respects, they are driven to this due to their loss of hope, but their acts also lead to a loss of hope in the reader; it all seems so unpreventable and irreparable with the circumstances being what they are.

Dysart also effectively utilizes the theme of “man and boy.”  The relationship of Moses and Paul reaches its inevitable end this issue, and the resulting conversation between the two is easily one of the most memorable and touching moments of the book.  While emotional, it also plays up the themes of innocence vs. experience and the necessity of hope.  It is incredibly moving to see Moses speak of the death of hope in the IDP camp, only to attempt to instill hope in Paul, painting an image of normal life that looks like paradise. The dichotomy that Dysart has been setting up between Moses and Paul has never been more striking; one has a future, the other does not.

While Dysart works wonders this month, Ponticelli continues to amaze me since changing the style and direction of his art.  I adore this dusty, painted feel he’s been employing and feel that it makes the book look much more refined, polished, and high level.  The murky, less distinct nature of it also lends well to Moses’  increasingly confused mental state.

Weekly Comic Book Review’s Top Picks

Alex’s Top Picks

Pick of the Week: Uncanny X-Men #522 – If only all of Fraction’s issues of Uncanny were so good.  The book shows what Fraction is truly capable of with the X-Men.  It’s unfortunate that we’re heading into a big event now, as I wouldn’t mind having a Kitty arc ASAP.

Most Anticipated: Madame Xanadu #21 -Amy Reeder Hadley returns again on art!  And no more flashbacks!  The best arc since the series’ first continues in earnest.  For anyone reading Xanadu, this should be at the top of the pile.

Other Picks: Fantastic Four #577, Blackest Night #8, Detective Comics #863, Unknown Soldier #18, Justice Society of America #37, The Sword #23

DS’s Top Picks

Best of the Past Week: Green Lantern #52 – Johns book knocked it out of the park! What a great way to set up the conclusion to Blackest Night!

Most Anticipated: Blackest Night #8 – I’m waiting for this issue to deliver a knockout punch reading experience in my very worthwhile investment in the Blackest Night event. And given how flawlessly Blackest Night has unfolded, I think my faith will be rewarded!

Other Top Picks: JLA #43, Wonder Woman #42