• Categories

  • Archives

  • Top 10 Most Read

The Sword #18 – Review

by Joshua Luna (writer & letterer) and Jonathan Luna (art)

The Story: Dara’s battle with the Earth god Knossos comes to its brutal and bloody conclusion.

What’s Good: Goddamn this was a brutal comic.  Once again, the Lunas prove that the Sword is sharp.  Damn sharp.  Limbs fly and people are gutted.  That said, it’s not brutal in a “random people exploding all over the place” sort of way.  It’s brutal because every single act of violence is loaded with emotional intent.  Every chopped limb actually means something.

The sheer scope and size of the battle is nothing short of ridiculous.  Its impossible to talk about the story of this issue without also mentioning the artwork, as the two go hand in hand in depicting the battle.  The Lunas do an amazing job of conveying the size of Knossos and the unbelievable odds against which Dara is fighting.  It’s the sort of awe-inspiring stuff  we’ve come to expect, and it leads to some unforgettable images.

I also loved the ending of the issue, which delivers a twist that provides the landscape for the coming battle with Malia.  It really is an unexpected turn that reshapes the world of the Sword.  It also guarantees that this series will have a very different feel as it heads into its last arc, and that the battle with Malia will be like none before; this time, with the world watching.  Not running the risk of repetition, the Lunas have changed the rules in shocking fashion.

What’s Not-So-Good: Unfortunately, the bottom-line is that this battle just wasn’t as fun as the one with Zakros.  In that battle, I marveled at the sheer creativity of the Lunas, giving the gods endless ways to use their powers.  Not so much in this issue, which sees Knossos stay in his rock man form.  It’s just a little more one dimensional than I’ve come to expect.

I also wasn’t a huge fan of Malia’s continued interference in Dara’s battle.  It made the conflict between Knossos and Dara feel less personal and less important.  The one-on-one dynamic was lost and thus so too was some of the impact.  I wanted Dara vs Knossos, and having it be Dara and Malia vs Knossos needlessly diluted the conflict.

The rock man form is also a bit of a double-edged sword as well.  While it provides some amazing visuals and an incredible obstacle for Dara, it also means that Knossos is encased in a giant suit of rock, unable to exchange banter with Dara while the fight goes on, which was part of what made the Zakros fight so awesome.  The one exchange of words at the end of the fight is perhaps the high point of the issue only serves to illustrate this fact.

Conclusion: By no means a bad conclusion, but it wasn’t quite as personal as we’ve come to expect.

Grade: B-

-Alex Evans

W.C.B.R. Top Picks!

Ray’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week: Detective Comics #854 – I hated the Batwoman character since 52, but now I’m find myself falling for her.

Most Anticipated for this Week: Justice League: Cry For Justice #1 – Ever since I saw the preview for this in last month’s issue of Batman and Robin, I simply couldn’t wait. It’s the story and the situation we all need to see.  The Justice League post the deaths of Batman and Martian manhunter…

Other Top Picks: Green Lantern Corps #38, Batman and Robin #2, Captain America Reborn #1, Marvel Divas #1, Uncanny X-Men #513, Anna Mercury #5, Ignition City #1, Irredeemable #4

Kyle’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week:  Sinister Spider-Man #1 – It may not be for everyone, but I enjoyed the hell out of what Brian Reed and Chris Bachalo put together.   Dark, twisted, and downright cool, Sinister Spider-Man is a Dark Reign tie-in definitely worth picking up.

Most Anticipated for this Week: Batman & Robin #2 – I rarely read DC, but the first issue of Batman and Robin left wanting more, a lot more.

Other Top Picks for this Week: Witchblade #128, Exiles #4, Agents of Atlas #7, Uncanny X-Men #513, Destroyer #4, Deadpool: Merc with a Mouth #1, Invincible Iron Man #15, and Chew #2

Rob’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week: Amazing Spider-Man #598- Hate to disagree with my friend and c0-editor here at WCBR Kyle, but I thought this week’s installment of American Son was an easy A. But then again, I’m in the tank for Kelly as much as he is for Obama.

Most Anticipated for this Week: Captain America Reborn #1- Can’t wait to see how this plays out. It is rare that I am excited on the outset  for a creative team, but Hitch and Brubaker is a pairing that I am psyched for.

Other Top Picks for this Week: Astounding Wolf-man #17; Batman and Robin #2; 
Battlestar Galactica Final Five #4 (of 4); Captain America Reborn #1 (of 5);
Destroyer #4 (of 5); Fantastic Four #568; Green Lantern Corps #38;  Uncanny x-men #513
; War of Kings #5; Irredeemable #4

Alex’s Top Picks


Best Of The PastWeek: Detective Comics #854 – Was there really any question?  Despite a game showing from Northlanders, Detective killed the competition for me.  The best art you can find in a DC book right now combine with crisp writing and a cowled character like no other in what is now my favourite Bat-book.  Oh, and the backup is pretty nifty too.  This was the first time in a long time that I paid the $4 without feeling gyped.

Most Anticipated: Greek Street #1 – WCBR readers probably know by now that I loves me some Vertigo.  A nasty as hell, gritty crime drama blends with a Gaiman-esque take on mythology that’s sure to yield an innovative and gripping tale.  Sign me up.  The fact that the book is in the capable hands of Peter Milligan (Hellblazer, Human Target) with art from Davide Gianfelice (Northlanders) sure doesn’t hurt.  I’m a sucker for insane, seemingly impossible genre/period mash-ups, so to say I’m looking forward to this is an understatement.

Other Top Picks for this Week: Astounding Wolf-Man #17, Captain America: Reborn #1, Uncanny X-Men #513, The Sword #18, Batman and Robin #2, Agents of Atlas #7, Green Lantern Corps #38, Destroyer #4

DS’s Top Picks

Best of the Past Week: Wonder Woman #33 – Gail Simone tied up the Rise of the Olympians arc with a couple of surprises in the end.

Most Anticipated for this Week: Strange Adventures #5 – I’m going to go for an odd pick this time, with Strange Adventures, because I really love Starlin and his cosmic stories.

Other Top Picks: Batman and Robin #2, Justice League: Cry for Justice #1, The Mighty #6

Weekly Comic Book Review’s Top Picks

Ray’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week – Superman: World of New Krypton #3
Most Anticipated for this Week – Green Lantern Corp. #36
Other Top Picks for this Week – Young Liars #15 and Action Comics #877

Kyle’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week – Exiles #2
Most Anticipated for this Week – Secret Warriors #4/Unwritten #1 (Tie)
Other Top Picks for this Week – Umbrella Academy #6, The Walking Dead #61, The Wonderful Wizard of Oz #6, Captain Britain & MI:13 #13, and Fusion #1

Rob’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week – Irredeemable #2
Most Anticipated for this Week – Battlestar Galactica: Final Five #2
Other Top Picks for this Week – Ultimate Spider-Man #132, Dark Tower: The Fall of Gilead #1, Green Lantern Corps #36, War of Kings: Ascension #2, Secret Warriors #4, The Walking Dead #61,and Unwritten #1

Alex’s Top Picks


Best of the Past Week – Shrapnel #5
Most anticipated for this Week – Secret Warriors #4
Other Top Picks for this Week – Unwritten #1, The Sword #18, The Green Lantern Corps. #36, The Walking Dead #61, Fables #84,

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started