Legion Lost #4 – Review

By: Fabian Nicieza (writer), Pete Woods (artist), Brad Anderson (colorist)

The Story: This—is—Fargoooo!!

The Review: To this day, I still don’t understand DC’s aversion to adopting Marvel’s recap page, which is one of the most practical, useful devices you can have in serial fiction.  And it’s not just Marvel; TV shows use the opening “Previously…” to the same effect for each episode, and many manga tend to start their issues with the last few panels from the preceding ones.  If the goal is to get new readers on board, a recap page would be a handy thing indeed.

Without one, you wind up with chunks of exposition awkwardly and repetitively laced into the narrative itself, like Dawnstar’s recollection of the past few issues’ events here: “The Legion of Super-Heroes came back in time to stop a terrorist named Alastor from releasing a deadly disease.  We failed.”  For anyone who’s been following along since the beginning, this only reiterates everything we’re already well aware of, and is thus a sad waste of time and space.

But then, Dawnstar’s entire narration feels a bit unnecessary.  Nicieza has always proven very comfortable writing internal dialogue (as demonstrated in a strong run on Red Robin), but since each issue switches the POV of the characters, you’re bound to get inconsistent results.  While Timber Wolf turned out to be a pretty entertaining narrator last issue, Dawnstar feels bland and pointless, making mostly redundant commentary on what’s happening: “I can feel their confusion through the mind-link, but also their hope—their determination to help [Yera]…”

Speaking of which, the happy return of Chameleon Girl is cut short when the Legionnaires find she can’t control the form she’s become attached to, that of human Hypertaxed into an Okaarian Rdrayyj.  At least you can rest easy knowing she’s still hanging in there, though it is a bit of a head-scratcher how they’ll get her out.  Besides, if she’s alive, there’s a pretty good chance Gates survived the big blow-up of issue one as well, so the Legion has reason to hope.