Ex Machina #50 – Review

by Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (art), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K. Fletcher

The Story: Ex Machina concludes with glimpse of the years following Mitchell’s time as mayor.

What’s Good: I can’t recall feeling so sad after reading the final issue of a series, not only because of the fact that a favourite book is concluding, but due to the content of the issue itself.  Ex Machina #50 is an emotionally devastating and draining experience for long-time readers who have become tied to Mitchell Hundred’s journey.  It’s poignant to be sure, but it’s hard to see this as anything but a tragedy.

But it’s not “true” tragedy, which is perhaps why it’s so emotionally affecting.  Mitchell Hundred does end up in a good position, professionally anyway, at issue’s end.  He has more power than ever and, in a stunning final couple of pages, is revealed to have ended up very near the pinnacle of American politics.  Of course, it’s all bittersweet to the extreme, because while Mitchell Hundred the politician has flourished, Mitchell Hundred the man finds himself an isolated wreck, irrevocably ruined and alone.  In the end, it’s as though these two sides of Hundred were ultimately impossible to maintain simultaneously, particularly under the weight of superheroics and alien powers.  Mitchell gets his power, but he paid the price.  In that sense, it’s more tragic than Hundred just ending up dead in an ending that is completely dire; this situation sees Hundred trapped in his professional position and forever rueful for what he personally lost, or destroyed, in the process.

And it’s that sense of loss that this gives issue a retrospective feel that is absolutely perfect for a final issue.  In projecting into the years going forward from his battle with Suzanne and his term as Mayor, Hundred ends up dogged by his past, hounded by it as it grows increasingly rotten.  This is brilliantly personified by a dream where he’s visited by his other-dimensional enemies, who, of course, visit him in the form of a twisted version of himself.  Meanwhile, in the real world, this is shown in the form of Bradbury, who on the one hand finds himself in ruins, but also finally lets his feelings for Hundred be known.  It’s a wonderful representation of the old Mitchell Hundred and that “past life” in its current state; rotten and deteriorated, but still not barren of its sincerity.

Ex Machina #49 – Review

by Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (art), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K. Fletcher (letters)

The Story: It’s the return of the Great Machine as Mitchell Hundred throws down with Suzanne, one last time.

What’s Good: Well, it finally happened.  In its second to last issue, Ex Machina finally became what no one ever thought it’d be: a superhero comic.  This makes for a really remarkable issue.  Ex Machina has been such a giant twist on the superhero genre that when it finally brings back some tried and true mechanics of that very genre, it feels shocking.  It also feels downright cool.

With the Great Machine taking to the skies once more, Vaughan and Harris hit us with some classic Superman imagery that is impossible not to smile and fist-pump at.  We get Mitchell Hundred doing the Clark Kent trademarked shirt-ripping.  Then we get onlookers on the ground pointing upwards, speculating on what some flying, and noisy, speck in the sky might be.  Seeing Vaughan turn Hundred into a bona fide superhero is awesome in ways that are indescribable.  The comic, by concept alone, has tried so hard to divorce Mitchell from superheroics that it’s really satisfying to see it all reversed, particularly given Hundred’s love for comics and superheroes.  For once, his efforts even see a grateful damsel in distress and an epic conclusion.  It’s a lot closer to the stories he was inspired by and certainly a far cry from his usual bumbling efforts as the Great Machine.

Ex Machina #47 – Review

by Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (art), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K. Fletcher (letters)

The Story: Suzanne hits Mitchell where it hurts.

What’s Good: This is one of those issues that shows how gifted Vaughan is as a writer.  Despite the frequent scene changes and time-leaps, not a page or word is wasted.  Absolutely nothing feels extraneous.   Also, unlike previous issues, the politics are present, but subdued and never jarring.  Rather, they enmesh themselves with the rest of the book, fluidly emulating the desperation of the rest of the plot.

What we get is a book that is beautifully cyclical and linked.  The first “present day” scene of the issue, for example, is oddly reminiscent of one of the first scenes of the entire series.  Similarly, the flashback, depicting a child Mitchell’s disbelief regarding DC’s use of a multiverse, is an odd but comfortable parallel to the present narrative.  After all, his problems stem from his finding out about a real-world “multiverse.”  It’s wonderful stuff, and when Hundred meets up once again with his childhood friend Ray, Vaughan does an amazing job with the dialogue; it’s clearly the same two kids with a “childish” dynamic, but they’re now confined to the adult world.

Hundred’s “dream” sequence, which sees him visiting the other dimension, is terrifying and surreal thanks to Harris’ efforts.  It’s also interesting how Vaughan uses his trademark Ex Machina issue structure to embody the “weirdness” of it.  It’s between the flashback and the present day portion of the issue, as though it exists in some liminal space beyond standard time.  Seeing Vaughan break the chronological structure he’s adhered to for so long only makes this scene more uncomfortable.

The real newsmaker though is Suzanne and the major character death in this issue.  It’s a serious gut punch and it ensures that Mitchell and Suzanne’s collision course will be highly personal. It’s a merciless move by Vaughan and it’s all the more shocking thanks to Tony Harris.  The murder is rendered in uncompromisingly violent, gory fashion that will definitely drop your jaw, especially considering how sudden it is, being the only action in the whole book.

Ex Machina #45 – Review

by Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (art), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K. Fletcher (letters)

The Story: Newly evil Suzanne Padilla makes her first move while Mayor Mitchell Hundred begins to plan his future.

What’s Good: The newly super-powered Suzanne Padilla makes for an utterly fantastic villain.  Vaughan has established a great voice for her that, after what we saw last month, is surprisingly very human and all the more successful for it.  Padilla sounds not at all like the sewer-dwelling robot of the past arc, and despite her appearance, even the lettering remains the same for the most part.  In this sense, she works better as a foil for Hundred.  Essentially, Vaughan has maintained the integrity of Padilla’s character; this new villain essentially sounds like her, with the confidence and arrogance cranked to the max.  The result is a villain that is more subtle, complex, oddly likable, and easily capable of carrying an entire arc.

Beyond this, we get from this issue what we’ve always gotten from Ex Machina.  The opening Great Machine flashback is, as always, both funny and poignantly appropriate, while all three of Hundred’s conversations with his various associates showing Vaughan’s complete mastery of his characters, each of them having the same distinct voices that we’ve come to know, with the interplay between personalities feeling natural and life-like.  The best of these was Hundred’s short conversation with Bradbury, which added well-placed humor to the book.  Vaughan has the two friends discuss some truly heavy subjects (Hundred even accuses Bradbury of murder), but all of it is done in such an affable manner.

Tony Harris meanwhile puts out some very strong work this issue.  In particular, he gets a little more creative this month with his panel layouts, which was a welcome surprise.  One dialogue scene at a firing range is especially well-done, with Harris pulling off some really slick layouts that manage to be both abstract and cinematic, the entire scene feeling very fluid.  I also love when artists use the spaces between panels to convey additional information.  I also loved Harris’ work on Padilla’s new look.  When disguising her new scars, she looks like a mysterious femme fatale straight out of a Raymond Chandler novel.  However, once exposed, she looks very alien, monstrous even.  The transition from 20s noir to the menace of modern science fiction is seamless and impressive on both ends.

What’s Not So Good: There’s a longish scene early on in the book where Wylie brings up the abortion issue, essentially trying to push Hundred into making a stand on the issue of unwanted pregnancies.  It’s too early to tell where this’ll go right now, but within this single issue, this subplot really felt out in the cold and detached from the rest of the book.  In fact, were it not for the date, I’d have believed the entire scene to be another flashback.  Ex Machina has always done a great job of combining its kookier superhero/sci-fi themes with more mundane hot-button political issues, but I’m starting to worry that as we head into this final arc, the crazy stuff has gotten a little too crazy to support this juggling act.  As a result, this political aspect of the issue felt a touch out of place and a little too low-key, and all the more surprisingly placed given that the entire series is ending.

Conclusion: Another issue of Ex Machina doing what it does best.

Grade: B+

-Alex Evans

Ex Machina #43 – Review

Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (pencils and inks), Jim Clark (inks), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K. Fletcher (letters)

The Story: With his political career teetering on the edge as the threat of Jack Pherson looms, will Mitchell Hundred don the helmet and jetpack one last time?

What’s Good: The greatest thing about this final story arc has been that it always leaves you craving for more.  This month’s comic is no different; with a cliffhanger ending that’ll have you chomping at the bit.  In fact, so potent is the ending that it legitimately feels as if next month’s issue will be the last in the series, despite there being six more after it.  Also, it makes Mitchell come across as a total badass, which is pretty cool, given that he has spent almost the entire series as a self-deprecating, likable, wisecracking everyman.

Considering how deep the mystery was last month, I didn’t think that Vaughan could ratchet up the tension any further.  Regardless, he does so this month by dropping these little hints that, right now, are unintelligible and yet promise so much.  What the heck happened on “November 6, 2001?”  What’s with “Jack Pherson” (if that is him) and his biblical language?  Who is he talking to and where did he come from?  And once again, though we actually see it this month, what in God’s name is the white box?  The mystery borders upon unbearable, showing that Vaughan is doing something right.

Not content with merely creating a thoroughly engaging final arc and conflict, however, Vaughan shows himself to be tireless in his development of Mitchell as a character.  His relationship with Kremlin deepens and softens and we finally, out of nowhere, get an answer regarding Mitchell’s sexuality in a manner that is sure to hit home.

Drawing this all up, of course, is Tony Harris who, despite a rocky start in issue 41, has really started to hit his stride again.  I didn’t spot any flagrantly static, “posed” frames this month, which is often a problem for him.  Furthermore, I really, really liked how dark the colors and how heavy the inks were.  It delivered a shadowy feel that really fit the sense of impending doom and enshrouding mystery.

What’s Not-so-Good: Despite a really cool ending, there are no revelatory moments this month and though those afore mentioned unintelligible hints are dropped, nothing is made sense of or explained.  Vaughan, while not at all treading water, doesn’t give you any answers this month.  He’s clearly working to suck you in, but this also means that he’s moving at a relatively leisurely pace; though the ending promises next month’s issue will be, at the very least, action-packed.  Though great, this month’s comic is a clear set-up issue.

Conclusion: Yup, this is definitely an Ex Machina comic.  A smart blend of the everyday and the weird with fantastic character-work and one hell of an ending.

Grade: B+

-Alex Evans

Ex Machina #42 – Review

by Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (pencils), Jim Clark (inks), JD Mettler (colors), and Jared K Fletcher (letters)

The Story: The mystery of the white box deepens as preparations are made for the Times Square New Year’s Eve celebrations.

The Good: This issue is “slow-burn” at its finest. Vaughan knows how to thicken the plot without frustrating the reader by writing a comic that is incredibly engaging. My curiosity regarding the “white box”– what it is, and the history behind it,  is reaching a fever pitch. Vaughan, through the suspense he delivers in this issue, really caused me to become invested in the mysteries surrounding this arc. I need next month’s issue and I need it now! From the veiled dialogue to the hints of how incredibly high the stakes are, this is build-up at its finest and an ideal example of how to get one’s readers sucked into a story arc.

Speaking of that “veiled dialogue,” the conversations and dialogue in general in this issue are incredibly well done. As always with Ex Machina, every character has his or her own unique voice. That said, what makes the dialogue so strong here is the mystery, weight, and/or foreshadowing that Vaughan makes every exchange carry. Every conversation elicits a strong sense of foreboding, either hinting at horrific things to come or at dark deeds of the past. Of course, this is only further aided by Ex Machina’s continual delivery of some of the smartest writing in comics today; especially when it comes to things conspiratorial or political.

Art-wise, I’m happy to say that Harris and friends have gotten it back together after a rushed misstep last month. The static and “posed” feel of Harris’s pencils are gone, as are the strangely bright colours. This issue returns to the Ex Machina we know and love. Also, it needs to be said that I really do like Harris’s Bioshock-esque design of Pherson version 2.0. Well, that is if that ominous figure at the end of the issue really is Pherson.

The Not-so-Good: This issue does a fantastic job of doing what Vaughan wanted it to do in crafting a clinic in foreshadowing and heightening suspense. However, that does by definition mean that not a lot of plot progression takes place. While it does ensure that what will come will be all the more impactful, if you’re the sort of reader who demands brisk action and development in every $3.00 purchase, you won’t be gratified by Ex Machina this month.

Conclusion: Ex Machina readers will enjoy this very solid build-up issue. If you weren’t interested in this story last month, you definitely will be now.  The biggest crime of this issue is it’s making you rabid for answers as it sucks you into its manifold mysteries.

Grade: B+

-Alex Evans

Ex Machina #34 – Review

By Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Tony Harris (penciller), Jim Clark (inker) & JD Mettler (colorist)

This is a stand alone issue, showing us Amy Angotti’s life. We get flashbacks as usual, but this time they are all related to her. Events chronicle how she grew up, met her husband as a lieutenant, and kicking ass at a bank robbery attempt. We get a couple of different points of view of previous events like Jack Pherson and Angotti fighting to bring the Great Machine down. At the end, Commissioner Angotti tells Hundred over the phone that she wants to work together with him. And just like Batman, the Great Machine receives a new signal.

Brian K. Vaughan delivers another solid story. This is, in particular, a great story for longtime fans of the series as we finally get a glimpse of Angotti’s back story. The issue also serves as ground base for future stories. Tony Harris’ art is stunning as usual. (Grade: B+)

-Daniel Yanez