
By Ed Brubaker, Roger Stern, Mark Waid (writers), Alex Ross, Dale Eaglesham, Butch Guice, Howard Chaykin, Rafael Albuquerque, David Aja, Mitch Breitweiser, and Kalman Andrasofszky (art), Frank D’Armata, Edgar Delgado, Matt Hollingsworth, Paul Mounts, Marte Gracia and Mitch Breitweiser (colors)
The Story: Everything you knew about the death of Captain America is wrong. On the eve of the one-year anniversary of that fateful day, Sharon follows a path built by fractured memories to discover a game-changing clue in Steve’s death. On the other side of town, while heading towards the memorial at Central Park, the Patriot meets a new hero from a different world, or at least she says, who has a particularly strong connection to both Bucky and Steve. Also attending the memorial is Bucky and the new avengers where they get a swift punch in the gut from Osborn, but not in the way you think.
What’s Good: Brubaker goes back to his mastery of spinning a mystery, crime noir story by starting with revisiting the first piece of evidence at any murder scene. From there, he weaves in hints of upcoming story-plots, centered around The Grand Director and this new, alien character, but then comes back to main issue at hand — Steve’s return. Most interesting is the surprise return of the Red Skull who we knew was out there somewhere, so don’t worry, I didn’t spoil anything here as its what he says that is the big reveal.
For me, it’s not just that Cap is back, but rather the whole series is back. I’ve felt that since Bucky became full-time Cap this story has been running on fumes and that all though it is extremely well written, it seemed like Brubaker was killing time or playing it safe. And this issue confirms my suspicions as all the dynamics, tone, feel, and even characters are back to where this series was at around issue 25. I’m no fan of Bucky being Cap at all, but who knows, the fact that this new direction is in full force and Cap is back, maybe it will retroactively sweeten Bucky’s roll for me? Also, there is a nice little vignette involving Crossbones and Sin that is sweet and yet so, so disturbing.
There is a team of artists on this book and I found each one of their parts to be executed to near perfection. My favorite was the art on the Red Skull tale, where the ultra-villain’s flash backs and current state were equally intense, his power and plans foreboding.
What’s Not So Good: As with all annual’s or event comics, like this “hundredth” issue, this pamphlet is a mixed bag as far as price. I’m not sure with the entire buzz and greatness imbued in Brubaker’s main tale, there was little worth reading in the smaller tales by Stern, Waid, and Lee. Waid’s didn’t make sense at all in the current marvel Universe as we see Tony Stark poised behind a desk with an assistant. Perhaps those that follow the Captain America Universe very tightly will have nostalgic feeling towards what these tales were about, but I didn’t and rather have had the extra cash to put towards another comic this week. I mean this comic was $5.30! That’s half of a decent trade. Tossing in these throwaway tales and cover gallery doesn’t justify the price point for me. I’m sure some collectors are happy with this and for them Marvel should offer two choices: a collector’s edition, like this issue, or a regular edition, with just Brubaker’s tale.
I think it is a fair critique to say that despite all the artists doing a yeoman’s job on their given task, the overall aesthetic feel for Brubaker’s main tale is jaded at best. Having Chaykin follow Guice next is like using a sponge instead of sandpaper. When I returned to the normal visual feel of Captain America at the end of the story, it felt like I was reading several other comics in between. Besides showcasing Marvel’s talent, there was nothing gained by using such radical art styles on one story. In fact, this decision hurt the book.
I know that Captain America has a rich history of team-ups, so I will wait and see how this eventual team-up between the Grand Director and this alien girl goes, but for now, I’m not sure that the Captain America mythos needs another partnership or anymore characters. Especially with the Skull and Steve returning.
Conclusion: Because of Captain America # 600, Reborn is by far the most anticipated event for me. This is the upcoming project helmed by Brubaker and Hitch that continues what was laid out here. I didn’t think anything could dampen the excitement around Blackest Night, but Steve’s return does. Most surprisingly, I am not pessimistic about how Steve’s resurrection will be handled as I have great faith in Brubaker and his talents, especially with crafting a good old-fashioned murder (or not) mystery. Brubaker’s story is an easy A, but with all the mishandled art oversight and expensive fluff stories, I have to give Captain America #600 an…
Grade: B
-Rob G.
Filed under: Marvel Comics, Reviews | Tagged: Alex Ross, Butch Guice, Captain America, Captain America # 600, Captain America # 600 - Review, Captain America Returns, comic books, Dale Eaglesham, David Aja, Ed Brubaker, Edgar Delgado, Frank D'Armata, Howard Chaykin, Kalman Andrasofszky, Mark Waid, Marte Gracia, Marvel Comic Book Reviews, Marvel Comics, Marvel Reviews, Matt Hollingsworth, Mitch Breitweiser, Paul Mounts, Rafael Albuquerque, Reborn, Roger Stern, Weekly Comic Book Review, weekly comic book reviews | Leave a comment »